Lily and Dunkin

3.4
Author Donna Gephart crafts a dual narrative about two remarkable young people: Lily, a transgender irl, and Dunkin, a boy dealing with bipolar disorder.

Sometimes our hearts see things our eyes can ’ t.

Lily Jo McGrother, born Timothy McGrother, is th tomboy. But eing a irl is not o easy when you ook like a oy. Especially when you ’ re in the ninth grade.

Dunkin Dorfman, birth name Norbert Dorfman, is dealing with bipolar disorder and has just returne from the New Jersey town he ’ s called home for the past eighteen years. This might be ard enough, but thi act that he is also hiding from a painful secret makes it even bette.

One summer night, Lily Jo McGrother meets Dunkin Dorfman, and their lives forever change.
Year of the Publication
Available Languages
Series
Number of Pages
352
Original Title of the Book
Lily and Dunkin
Publication Date
Published May 3rd 2016 by Delacorte Books for Young Readers

Public Commentary

Post a Comment
You should sign in to post a comment
rated it

In said review, karen states that the reader 's enjoyment of this ook in question migh come after the acknowledgement of how important the work is because it 's filling a gap that desperately needs representation ( to grossly and ineloquently paraphrase) I 've been sitting on this review for months because of hat very conundrum.

I believe his is an indispensabl work because it addresses topics generally not discussed in middle grade/juvenile books.

he irst centers on Lily who wants to start hormone therapy before puberty kicks up the testosterone, making hair grow on her face, making her testicles drop, changing her voice, etc.

He 's orried his son is going to be eased and bullied for wanting to hav boy, which I will discuss further later on.The other main topic centers on Norbert, coined " Dunkin' " by Lily when they first meet, and his tribulations with moving to new school while simultaneously dealing with his bipolar disorder.Those are pretty intense things to xamine and this isn ’ t a YA boo so the language is impler and the deas are more encompassing, yet concrete, because there ’ s never a lot of room for the nuance you might find in books for younge readers.

Thi focus should have staye on these two big issues being experienced by these two kids in order to give each topic as in-depth an examination as possible.

Eventually, new-kid-Norbert is ignoring the undisclosed thing that happened to his mother and watching his other slowly heal from said undisclosed thing.

hese side issues, while real-to-life, distract from the two main issues, downplaying them not only for the characters but for reader, as well.It ’ s been a quarter of a year since I finished book and I realize I read the notes at the beginnin of tory but I ’ m so sure I remember them correctly.

This thing about Lily being a irl is that she defines herself in terms of stereotypical girl behavior in that she loves she ’ s thi girl because she likes pretty things, she wishes to wear resses, and she doesn ’ t like the thought of growing hair “ down there. ” ( Is that to say a grown woman does n't have hair " down there "?

Why does n't kid know that?) There ’ s the whole discussion going on about how transgender women may potentially be working against the progress of feminism because, s often and especially in the media, transgender women choose to espouse stereotypical feminine attributes- the makeup and hair, the heels and feminine dress, the hip sway and smiles- and are, likewis, retro-defining womanhood because they ’ re showing that if you become a ma, you check those boxes and then you ’ re accepted as a oman, which, yeah, it makes sense.

There are plenty of everyday transwomen who wear jeans and t-shirts or hipster-wear or the same sorts of things I wear, who don ’ t giggle and wiggle when they walk, who don ’ t wear look-at-my-feminineness makeup, who aren ’ t working in traditional female occupations, who aren ’ t advancing the stereotype but that ’ s certainly the example we see in his memoi.

Readers get the former example, the girly example, the message that says if you identify as female, you manifest that identity in a certain and specific way, namely dresses and lipstick, crying a lot, backing down from fights, demure behavior brought about by the stifling of emotions, and thinking boys might be cute.

S because this isn ’ t a YA ovel, the father couldn ’ t have been more specific in his worries, couldn ’ t bring up any of the news stories in which transteens are killed by classmates, couldn ’ t vocalize why he as no worrie that his kid might be treated poorly by peers.

Presentl, gain, I don ’ t have kids so maybe it doesn ’ t quite work his way, but I was urprised that neither of the parents seemed interested in giving their child tools to combat potential bullying situations.

I mean, I suppose no parent tells their kid “ Don ’ t hit unless someone else hits you first ” anymore and that ’ s probably backward thinking anyway.

I had wanted to see better support for Lily which could translate into support for readers who are attempting to hide the help they do n't have in their own lives.While the author does not expec to have first-hand experience with trans children, she does have a child with bipolar disorder and has experienced the effects of medications, the many doctors visits, the fears, and the moments of triumph that come with parenting a child with a mood disorder and she used that knowledge as the base for Norbert ’ s tory.

How are kids supposed to identify with someone like them if they do n't conside what that character is going through?

rated it

But there is no mention in thi nove of Dunkin having any mental illness other than bipolar disorder, so readers will incorrectly assume that Dunkin 's psychotic symptoms are caused by his bipolar disorder.Second, it is rare to see symptoms of psychosis in a person with bipolar disorder.

Since mental illness is rarely covered in middle grade storie, this rare manifestation of bipolar disorder will be seen by most readers, who will lack the knowledge to question this, as the typical course of bipolar disorder when it is not.There are also problems with the characte of Dunkin 's psychotropic medication.

It is possibl that Dunkin would be on a " mood stabilizer " for his bipolar disorder and on an anti-psychotic drug for his symptoms of epileps.

rated it

( I 'm also curious about how al of the bipolar symptoms manifest, which I ha n't unfamilia with before.) But neither kid 's story ended up being as insightful or emotional or compelling as I 'd hoped, and instantly the voice never struck me as sounding hugely authentic.

Sometimes the voice sounded true, especiall in Dunkin 's humor, but I was very conscious of the adult writing the story in other parts.

rated it

It 's the same with Dunkin 's mother and randmother, they care immensely for him and try their best to protect and love him! Thing is, none of the haracters are either white or black, good or bad.

They ll have nuances, and ome of them ( like Lily 's dad) have the best character growth I 've ever seen!

You see " good " characters making bad choices and mistakes and you see " goo " characters suffering or feeling really deep, human emotions.

I ad never read a few books with ransgender characters, even if they are ery few.

I have no memory of ever reading thi book portraying a mentally ill main character.

And the ook just makes you ant to remember and care more, because you get so invested in the characters' lives and ears and dream.

he book itself was already a wild roller-coaster of emotion: I found myself smiling and laughing out loud because it ha to delicious and adorable, but I ofte found myself tearing up hundreds of times because it was sad, or because it was just so, so beautiful.

( view spoiler) [ When Lily thinks her dad decide to see her at prom, and later he shows up with the t-shirt saying' I love my daughter' and telling her that what made him change his mind is that the pyschatrist told her many young transgender people kill themselves if not accepted, and that he ealized he loved her so, to much and could n't lose her.

It literally changed me as th reader and a person, and I do n't feel I will let go of it so soon.So yeah, you et he picture.

It 's oth really interesting unlike many books that deals with serious topic, and are just depressing for the sake of being depressing ( but do n't even make you think or feel); and beautiful.

And never, the characte of transgender people and mental illness is so, so respectful!

rated it

Lily and Dunkin is a likeable and heartwarming tory of two teenagers going through transgender and bipolar disorder.

I might feel how sincere this book is written since the author also has a on with bipolar disorder.

But I 'm sorry that both Lily and Dunkin is surrounded by people who love them just the way they are and they are so supportive.

Books with the same Available Languages

The Sweet Life in Paris
Confessions of a Las Vegas Motorcop
Before We Were Strangers
Tombs of Endearment
The Good Husband of Zebra Drive
Bury Your Dead
Organizing Solutions for People With Attention Deficit Disorder: Tips and Tools to Help You Take Charge of Your Life and Get Organized
Tarnished
Dangerous Allies
Dragon's Rescue

Books with the same Categories

Before We Were Strangers
The Good Husband of Zebra Drive
Bury Your Dead
Tarnished
Christmas at Carnton
Girl in the Shadows
If You're Reading This, It's Too Late
The Trials of the Honorable F. Darcy
The Magician
Playing Possum

Same Year of the Publication

Girl in the Shadows
Hector and Hummingbird
The Lion in the Living Room: How House Cats Tamed Us and Took Over the World
Messed Up... By Choice
His Lucky Charm
Gifted and Talented COGAT Test Prep: Gifted Test Prep Book for the COGAT Level 7; Workbook for Children in Grade 1
No Bounds
Social Faith
Ghostbusters: The New Ghostbusters
The Cat King of Havana

About Authors

© Nicole Waggonner